logo

Sonia Gandhi’s memoir ignites Savarkar controversy, Shiv Sena protests, demands ban on book

Sonia Gandhi’s memoir ignites Savarkar controversy, Shiv Sena protests, demands ban on  book

The publication of Congress leader Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging – A Journey of Love, has opened a fresh front in the political battle over India’s history, nationalism and ideological identity. What was intended as a personal account of her life and political journey has quickly turned into a major controversy over the legacy of Hindutva ideologue and freedom fighter Vinayak Damodar Savarkar. The Shiv Sena has accused Gandhi of making objectionable and prejudiced remarks against Savarkar, describing the book as an attempt to malign a respected national figure. The party has not only demanded a ban on its distribution but has also taken its protest to the streets, with leaders tearing pages from the memoir in Mumbai. 

At a press conference in Mumbai on Wednesday, Shiv Sena leaders, including national spokesperson Sanjay Nirupam, strongly criticised the contents of the 544-page memoir published by HarperCollins India. Party leader Anand Dubey alleged that the book was filled with hostility towards Savarkar, whom he described as a symbol of brilliance, sacrifice, discipline and extraordinary courage. Recalling Savarkar’s imprisonment in the Cellular Jail in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, Dubey said his years of suffering under British rule could not be ignored or diminished. He objected to the portrayal of Savarkar in the memoir and participated in the symbolic tearing of its pages. Nirupam, a former Congress leader, went further, accusing Sonia Gandhi of repeatedly targeting Savarkar for political reasons. He referred to former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi’s contribution towards a memorial dedicated to Savarkar and alleged that Sonia Gandhi had opposed the installation of his portrait in Parliament. He also recalled her letter to then President A P J Abdul Kalam on the issue. Demanding a ban on the book, Nirupam tore out the page containing the controversial observations.

The objection centres on Gandhi’s account of Savarkar’s conduct during British rule. In the memoir, she contrasts the imprisonment and suffering of Congress freedom fighters with the mercy petitions submitted by Savarkar to the colonial authorities. She also alleges that some RSS members collaborated with British officials as informers. In another passage, Gandhi describes Savarkar’s Hindutva ideology as a political vision that places Hindu identity at the centre of India's national character, linking it to the RSS, BJP and their associated organisations. These observations have provoked a strong reaction from the Shiv Sena, which considers Savarkar an important figure in Maharashtra’s political and cultural history.

The Congress, however, has rejected the political attack and accused the RSS of consistently viewing the Grand Old Party as a stumbling block. The controversy has also put Shiv Sena (UBT) chief Uddhav Thackeray in an uncomfortable position, with Sena spokesperson and deputy leader Sheetal Mhatre questioning his political association with the Congress under the Maha Vikas Aghadi arrangement. The episode exposes the continuing ideological contradictions in Maharashtra politics, where parties that once shared political ground now find themselves divided over fundamental questions of history and national identity.

Beyond the immediate confrontation, the controversy reflects how historical personalities continue to influence present-day political discourse. Savarkar remains a deeply debated figure, with sharply differing interpretations of his role in the freedom movement and his political philosophy. While the Congress has chosen to present its interpretation in the memoir, the Shiv Sena has responded with an aggressive political protest. The demand for a ban has added another dimension to the dispute, raising questions about the balance between freedom of expression, historical interpretation and political sensitivity.

Leave Your Comment

 

 

Top